What a High Cholesterol Number Can and Can't Tell You

What a High Cholesterol Number Can and Can't Tell You

In 2016, a group of researchers went looking for every study that had followed people over 60 and recorded both their LDL cholesterol and when they died. They found 19 studies, covering 30 separate groups and 68,094 people.

If LDL were simply poison, the people with the most of it should have died first. They didn't. For groups covering 92% of those people, higher LDL went with living as long or longer. In the rest, it made no difference. In none of them did higher LDL go with dying sooner.

There's an obvious objection, and it's a fair one. Serious illness can push cholesterol down, so some of the people with the lowest numbers may simply have been the sickest. And on the other side stands a large body of evidence. In 2017, the European Atherosclerosis Society pulled together genetic studies, more than 200 cohort studies and trials in over two million people, and concluded that LDL causes the hardening of the arteries behind most heart attacks.

Both findings are real, and together they say something useful. A high cholesterol number on its own says much less than it seems to. Whether it matters depends on what else is going on in the body that made it. Cholesterol isn't something that sneaks in from your breakfast. Your body makes it on purpose, and raises the supply when something calls for it.

What cholesterol is for

The name records where it was first found. In 1769, the Frenchman François Poulletier de la Salle found it in solid form in gallstones, and in 1815 it was named after them, from the Greek kholē, bile, and stereos, solid.

Most of your cholesterol is made in your own body, mainly in the liver, and it's in every cell you have. It's part of every cell membrane, where it keeps the wall firm but flexible. It's the raw material for every steroid hormone: cortisol and aldosterone from the adrenal glands, and the sex hormones oestrogen, progesterone and testosterone. It's where vitamin D starts, and the liver turns it into the bile you need to digest fat.

Eating cholesterol changes the cholesterol in your blood less than you'd think. Most of the cholesterol in food is poorly absorbed, and when more comes in, the body makes less of its own. In 2015, the scientific panel behind the US dietary guidelines dropped the old limit of 300 milligrams a day, though the guidelines still advise keeping it as low as a healthy diet allows.

The brain is especially rich in it. About a quarter of all the cholesterol in your body sits there, most of it in myelin, the insulation around nerve fibres. The brain makes almost all of its own, behind the blood-brain barrier, and keeps recycling it.

Cholesterol's carriers have a job in defence too. The particles that carry it around the blood, LDL among them, can bind the toxins that leak from the walls of certain bacteria. In 1996, a Dutch team bred mice whose LDL ran far higher than normal and challenged them with one of those bacterial toxins. The high-LDL mice survived about eight times as much of the toxin as ordinary mice could, and they did better with a live bacterial infection too. A mouse isn't a person, but it's a reminder that the particle with the bad name has work to do.

How a plaque forms

The cholesterol story began with rabbits. In 1913, in St Petersburg, Nikolai Anitschkow fed rabbits cholesterol and found fatty streaks and plaques in their arteries, more of them the more he fed. It was a landmark, and it shaped a century of research. It was also a rabbit, an animal whose natural diet contains almost no cholesterol.

In people, a plaque doesn't start with cholesterol floating past. It starts with a damaged patch on the inside of an artery wall.

At that patch, white blood cells move into the wall and turn into scavenger cells. These scavengers swallow LDL that has been oxidised, damaged by oxygen the way butter goes rancid. Packed with it, they swell into what are called foam cells, and they die and leave a fatty streak behind. Over years, the streak can grow into a plaque, and plaques are what most heart attacks start from.

Notice the word oxidised. The particles the scavengers go after are the damaged ones. So the questions that matter most are what damaged the wall, and what damaged the LDL.

It would be dishonest to stop there, though. The more LDL particles pass through the arteries, and the longer they do it, the more chances there are for some of them to end up in a damaged wall. The clearest case is familial hypercholesterolaemia, an inherited fault in the receptors that clear LDL from the blood. It affects about one person in 250. Their LDL runs high from birth, and heart disease can arrive decades early. For them, the number itself is a large part of the problem, and treatment matters. The clues are worth knowing: LDL that's very high from a young age, a parent or sibling with early heart disease, and yellow cholesterol deposits in the tendons of the hands, knees and heels, around the eyelids, or as a pale ring at the edge of the iris. It's passed down from one parent, so each child of someone who has it has a one-in-two chance of inheriting it, which makes one diagnosis a reason to test the family.

What damages the wall

For the rest of us, the useful work starts upstream, with the things that damage arteries and LDL in the first place.

Oxidised fat. Seed oils such as sunflower, soybean and corn oil carry a lot of polyunsaturated fat, which breaks down with heat and oxygen into reactive compounds. From Soap Factory to Frying Pan: How Seed Oils Got Here explains the chemistry, and the trials where swapping animal fat for seed oil lowered cholesterol without saving lives. The same article covers how these oils pushed omega-6 far ahead of omega-3 in what we eat today. Oily fish brings the omega-3 back, and a Omega 3 Fish Oil is the concentrated version, though no capsule makes up for a kitchen still cooking in seed oil.

Blood sugar. Sugar that stays high in the bloodstream attaches itself to proteins and changes how they behave, a process called glycation, and the triglyceride section below shows where else sugar turns up on the test.

Inflammation that never switches off. Chronic inflammation keeps the artery wall under steady fire. It comes from many places, including poor sleep, constant stress and a mouth with gum disease, which What Keeps Chronic Inflammation Switched On shows can lift the body's inflammation marker in the blood.

Homocysteine. This is a by-product of normal metabolism that B vitamins help clear, and high levels go with heart disease. It's worth knowing your level, but the link isn't as simple as it looks. In a trial of 5,522 people with vascular disease or diabetes, B vitamins lowered homocysteine for five years, but didn't reduce heart attacks or deaths from heart disease. Strokes did fall. So homocysteine looks more like a sign of trouble than a lever that fixes it.

The fat in the pan

If oxidation is the problem, the fat you cook with matters. Saturated fat lacks the weak double bonds that oxygen goes for, so butter, ghee, lard and tallow stay stable in a hot pan where seed oils break down. That's the core of the argument for cooking with animal fat. How saturated fat got the blame in the first place is the subject of The Big Fat Surprise: Why Butter, Meat and Cheese Belong in a Healthy Diet, in which the journalist Nina Teicholz goes back through the studies and the committee decisions behind the advice.

Then there's where the calcium goes. Arterial plaque hardens with calcium, and the body has a protein whose job is to stop that. It's called Matrix Gla Protein, and it only works once vitamin K has activated it. In the Rotterdam Study, which followed 4,807 people for up to ten years, the third with the highest vitamin K2 intake had a 57% lower death rate from heart disease than the lowest third, and about half the odds of severe calcification in the aorta. Vitamin K1, the kind in leafy greens, showed no link at all. One form of K2 is made in animal tissues, so it comes with animal food, and longer forms come from fermented foods. For those who supplement, Vitamin D3 + K2 pairs K2 with vitamin D.

What the number misses

A standard cholesterol test gives you total cholesterol, LDL, HDL and triglycerides. LDL usually gets all the attention, but the others say a lot.

Triglycerides are the fats your liver packs up and sends out, and they answer strongly to sugar and starch. The usual advice for lowering them starts with cutting carbohydrates, sugary drinks and fructose above all. High triglycerides with low HDL is the classic warning pattern. Low triglycerides with high HDL tells a calmer story, even when the LDL is high.

Even the "good" cholesterol has a limit. In two Copenhagen studies of more than 116,000 people, the risk of dying fell as HDL rose, but only up to a point. It was lowest at around 73 mg/dL for men and 93 for women. Men with HDL of 116 or more had about twice the death rate of men at the sweet spot, and women above 135 about two-thirds more. The researchers called it a paradox and asked for more studies to confirm it. It's one more reason no single cholesterol number tells the whole story.

Some markers aren't on the standard test and have to be asked for: ApoB, which reflects how many LDL particles there are rather than how much cholesterol they carry; a measure of inflammation such as hs-CRP; homocysteine; and fasting glucose and insulin. A high LDL can also point somewhere else entirely. An underactive thyroid can raise cholesterol, LDL and lipoprotein(a), so a thyroid test, TSH, belongs on the list when LDL climbs for no obvious reason.

One more is worth testing once: lipoprotein(a), a version of the LDL particle with an extra protein attached. Its level is set mostly by your genes, through a single gene called LPA, and diet and exercise move it only slightly. Genetic and population studies link high levels to heart disease and stroke. Because it barely changes over a lifetime, one test usually tells you where you stand.

The most striking case of LDL going its own way comes from people on very low-carbohydrate diets. Some lean, fit people on a ketogenic diet see their LDL shoot up, with high HDL and very low triglycerides. They've been nicknamed lean mass hyper-responders. In 2024, a team compared 80 of them, with an average LDL of 272 mg/dL after almost five years on the diet, against 80 matched people whose LDL averaged 123. The amount of plaque in their coronary arteries was no different, and LDL level didn't track with plaque in either group. It's one small study that looked at a single moment rather than following people over time, and its findings are argued over. But it shows how much the same LDL number can mean different things in different bodies.

The scan that looks at the artery

Blood tests are indirect. A coronary artery calcium scan looks at the arteries themselves. It's a quick, low-radiation CT scan that counts the calcium in the coronary arteries, and calcium is where hardened plaque shows up. The score is an independent marker of the risk of heart attacks and death, and it adds something to every other test.

A score of zero is reassuring, though not a guarantee, as soft plaque that hasn't calcified yet can still be there, especially in younger people. A score that rises over the years shows plaque building. Set next to a blood test, it can turn a worrying number into a calm one, or the other way round.

Cholesterol is the message

A high cholesterol result is a reason to look more closely, not a verdict. Ask what your triglycerides and HDL say. Ask for ApoB and a measure of inflammation. Think about what might be damaging your arteries: the oil you cook with, your blood sugar, how you sleep, the state of your gums. And if you're already taking a statin, talk any change through with whoever prescribed it first. An article is no place to decide that.

Your body makes cholesterol because it needs it, for every cell, every hormone and every nerve. When it makes more, the question worth asking is why. Cholesterol is the message. Treating it as the whole problem is how the message gets missed.


Wondering how seed oils got into every kitchen? From Soap Factory to Frying Pan: How Seed Oils Got Here — the lamp oil that became heart food, and what heat does to it.

What keeps the body inflamed, and how do you turn it down? What Keeps Chronic Inflammation Switched On — the hidden sources, from the gut to the gums.


Know someone who was handed a cholesterol number and nothing else? Send them this. The number is the start of the story, not the end of it.

Tried something here, or got a question it didn't answer? Write to us at contact@allforlife.club. Your questions shape the next articles.


Disclaimer: This article is general information, not medical or nutritional advice. For advice about your own health, talk to a qualified health professional. Don't stop or change any prescribed medicine without talking to whoever prescribed it.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, All For Life earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. We only link to products we would recommend without the commission.

Sources

Ravnskov U, Diamond DM, Hama R, Hamazaki T, Hammarskjöld B, Hynes N, Kendrick M, Langsjoen PH, Malhotra A, Mascitelli L, McCully KS, Ogushi Y, Okuyama H, Rosch PJ, Schersten T, Sultan S, Sundberg R (2016). Lack of an association or an inverse association between low-density-lipoprotein cholesterol and mortality in the elderly: a systematic review. BMJ Open 6(6):e010401. doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2015-010401

Ference BA, Ginsberg HN, Graham I, et al. (2017). Low-density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. 1. Evidence from genetic, epidemiologic, and clinical studies. A consensus statement from the European Atherosclerosis Society Consensus Panel. European Heart Journal 38(32):2459–2472. doi.org/10.1093/eurheartj/ehx144

Wikipedia. Cholesterol. en.wikipedia.org

Björkhem I, Meaney S (2004). Brain Cholesterol: Long Secret Life Behind a Barrier. Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology 24(5):806–815. doi.org/10.1161/01.ATV.0000120374.59826.1b

Netea MG, Demacker PN, Kullberg BJ, Boerman OC, Verschueren I, Stalenhoef AF, van der Meer JW (1996). Low-density lipoprotein receptor-deficient mice are protected against lethal endotoxemia and severe gram-negative infections. Journal of Clinical Investigation 97(6):1366–1372. doi.org/10.1172/JCI118556

Finking G, Hanke H (1997). Nikolaj Nikolajewitsch Anitschkow (1885–1964) established the cholesterol-fed rabbit as a model for atherosclerosis research. Atherosclerosis 135(1):1–7. doi.org/10.1016/S0021-9150(97)00161-5

Wikipedia. Atherosclerosis. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Familial hypercholesterolemia. en.wikipedia.org

Lonn E, Yusuf S, Arnold MJ, et al. (2006). Homocysteine Lowering with Folic Acid and B Vitamins in Vascular Disease. New England Journal of Medicine 354(15):1567–1577. doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa060900

Geleijnse JM, Vermeer C, Grobbee DE, et al. (2004). Dietary Intake of Menaquinone Is Associated with a Reduced Risk of Coronary Heart Disease: The Rotterdam Study. The Journal of Nutrition 134(11):3100–3105. doi.org/10.1093/jn/134.11.3100

Wikipedia. Vitamin K2. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Hypertriglyceridemia. en.wikipedia.org

Madsen CM, Varbo A, Nordestgaard BG (2017). Extreme high high-density lipoprotein cholesterol is paradoxically associated with high mortality in men and women: two prospective cohort studies. European Heart Journal 38(32):2478–2486. doi.org/10.1093/eurheartj/ehx163

Wikipedia. Hypothyroidism. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Lipoprotein(a). en.wikipedia.org

Budoff M, Manubolu VS, Kinninger A, et al. (2024). Carbohydrate Restriction-Induced Elevations in LDL-Cholesterol and Atherosclerosis. JACC: Advances 3(8):101109. doi.org/10.1016/j.jacadv.2024.101109

Wikipedia. Coronary CT calcium scan. en.wikipedia.org