Plant Toxins: Why Vegetables Fight Back When You Eat Them

Plant Toxins: Why Vegetables Fight Back When You Eat Them

For years I recommended vegetables, salads, juices, smoothies, whole grains and beans with complete conviction. I steered people away from red meat and argued with those who questioned the plants. More plants meant better health, and I said so with the confidence of someone who had never looked at the other side of the plate.

What cracked it open was a book, Jacek Safuta's Myth of Incurable Diseases and Big Business, and one study it pointed me to. Sixteen volunteers spent ten weeks on a strictly controlled diet with almost no fruit or vegetables, as part of a trial testing green tea. The tea did very little. The diet did more: damage to their DNA, their blood proteins and their blood fats went down, not up, and their antioxidant defences shifted markedly. The researchers wrote that the trial had essentially become a fruit and vegetable depletion study.

It was small, and the finding was a side effect of a different question. A later trial from the same group found that 600 grams of fruit and vegetables a day strengthened some antioxidant defences, so the story isn't one-sided. But that first result made me ask something I had never asked. What else are these plants doing while they feed me?

Why vegetables fight back

An animal under threat runs. A plant can't, so it fights with chemistry. Plants produce compounds that repel, sicken or slow down whatever is eating them, from insects and fungi to grazing mammals, and they spend real energy making them.

Those weapons don't switch off at harvest. They're still in the seed, the leaf and the root when it reaches your plate, and some of them are concentrated in exactly the foods we've been told to eat more of. The list is long, but five compounds matter most at an ordinary table. Four are true plant toxins: lectins, oxalates, phytate and the plant oestrogens in soy. The fifth, fructose, is bait, the sugar a fruit uses to get its seeds carried away, and it causes trouble in quantity.

Some of the ones left out are dramatic but easy to avoid. The kernels inside apricot stones carry amygdalin, which releases cyanide in the body. Since the 1950s it has been sold as a cancer treatment under the name vitamin B17. It isn't a vitamin, studies found it useless against cancer, and it carries a real risk of cyanide poisoning. The same compound sits in bitter almonds and, in smaller amounts, in apple pips, one more case of the plant guarding its seeds hardest.

Lectins

Lectins are proteins that latch onto sugars, including the sugars on the surface of your own cells. When pulses were tested side by side, soybeans and common beans held far more lectin than peas, lentils or chickpeas. In beans, lectins serve as a defence: legume lectins have been studied as natural insecticides because they harm the pests that eat them.

The name says what they do. Lectin was coined in 1954 from the Latin lectus, chosen, from legere, to pick out, because each one picks out particular sugars. Some are choosy enough to tell blood groups apart, and are still used in blood typing.

The family includes one of the most notorious poisons there is. Ricin, from the seeds of the castor oil plant, uses a lectin to grip a cell's surface and get itself inside. The first lectin on record is ricin itself, isolated in 1888 by a student at the University of Dorpat, in what is now Estonia. Food lectins are far milder, but the most famous of them, phytohaemagglutinin in red kidney beans, can bring on violent vomiting from a handful of undercooked beans. Why Your Fruits and Vegetables Deliver Less Than You Think has the numbers on that one, and why a slow cooker can leave it intact.

Lectins have one weakness. They're fragile. Soaking pulses in water lowered their lectins, and cooking did far more. Fermentation helps too. The problem is the shortcuts: undercooked beans, raw sprouts, flour that never got hot. I cook beans in a pressure cooker on the rare occasions I eat them, because it takes them well past boiling point, and the same pot turns bones into broth while I do something else.

What lectins do in the long run is less settled than some books claim. A paper in the BMJ in 1999 argued that dietary lectins might contribute to conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis and type 1 diabetes. It was a hypothesis, and it still hasn't been properly tested in people. What is certain is that these proteins exist to deter animals, and some studies have found they may get in the way of absorbing minerals such as iron and zinc. The Plant Paradox makes the full case against them.

Oxalates

Oxalate is a small, sharp molecule that binds calcium. Plants use it to store calcium and to make themselves unpleasant to eat. In us, it grabs calcium in the gut and leaves with it, or it gets absorbed and leaves through the kidneys, and that's where the trouble starts. About three in four kidney stones are made of calcium oxalate.

The richest sources sit at the centre of superfood culture: spinach and its relatives, beet and chard, along with rhubarb.

Rhubarb carries a history lesson. During the First World War, its leaves were wrongly recommended as food in Britain, and people were poisoned. The advice was rediscovered in the Second World War and handed out again, and more people died. It took large amounts eaten over time, but the leaves are full of oxalic acid, which is why we eat only the stalks.

And one source hides in plain sight. When the oxalate in English diets was added up, an ordinary day came to 70 to 150 milligrams, and tea supplied more of it than anything else. Three cups of tea and a spinach salad is a lot of oxalate from foods chosen for their health halo.

Then came the green smoothie, which puts more raw leaves into a single glass than you'd ever get through with a knife and fork. One case report describes a 65-year-old woman whose kidneys failed after a green smoothie juice cleanse. They had been working normally before it. She did have risk factors, an old gastric bypass and a recent long course of antibiotics, both of which let more oxalate through. But the cleanse was the trigger, and her kidneys never recovered.

The antibiotics matter more than they sound. A gut bacterium, Oxalobacter formigenes, lives on oxalate and breaks it down before it can be absorbed. It was first found in the gut of a sheep in 1985. Broad-spectrum quinolone antibiotics kill it, and how common it is depends on where you live: about three in four people carry it in Japan and South Korea, and just three in ten in the United States. Without it, more of the oxalate on your plate ends up in your kidneys.

Cooking changes the picture. Boiling leaches oxalate into the water: boiled vegetables lost 30 to 87% of their soluble oxalate, steamed ones only 5 to 53%, and the lost oxalate ended up almost entirely in the pot. So boil, and pour the water away. Raw spinach in a salad or a smoothie is the worst way to eat it.

To be honest about the extreme claims, the cases of oxalate crystals lodged in bones and joints come mainly from a rare inherited disease, once the kidneys have already failed. Outside that disease, the cost shows up in the kidneys and in the calcium the oxalate takes with it. That's reason enough to keep greens at the edge of the plate and out of the blender. Toxic Superfoods goes through the foods responsible in detail.

Phytate

Whole grains, beans, nuts and seeds keep most of their phosphorus as phytate, also called phytic acid. Phytate grips calcium, iron and zinc and forms clumps your gut can't absorb. The minerals are in the food. They just never make it into you.

Cows and sheep tell the story. They digest phytate without trouble, because the microbes in their rumen make an enzyme, phytase, that breaks it apart. Pigs, chickens and people, with no rumen, can't. A cow eats the grass and the grain, and we eat the cow, with the phytate left behind. Eat the grain yourself and part of its minerals goes with the phytate.

Rickets showed the same thing a century ago. While investigating the disease in London in the 1910s, the British biochemist Edward Mellanby fed caged dogs a diet of porridge, and they developed rickets. Cod liver oil cured them. The missing piece turned out to be vitamin D, which the skin makes in sunlight, but Mellanby went on to study the harm done by cereals rich in phytic acid, and a diet high in phytate and low in calcium can still bring rickets on.

In people today, zinc is the clearest case. A diet heavy in phytate-rich whole grains is one recognised cause of zinc deficiency, and wholegrain cereals are listed as good zinc sources with the warning that their phytate reduces how much you take up. Traditional kitchens had an answer: soaking in something acidic, sprouting, and fermenting, as in sourdough or pickling, all break phytate down. Plain water is the weak link. When pulses were soaked in plain water, their lectins and oxalates fell, but their phytate didn't move.

Modern habits skip all of this. Overnight oats are soaked, but usually in plain milk rather than anything acidic. Fast-rise bread skips the long sourdough ferment. The supplement aisle then sells back the minerals the breakfast took away.

Fructose

Fruit sugar has the best reputation of any sugar, because it comes from fruit. In the body, it takes a road of its own. Glucose feeds cells everywhere. Fructose heads for the gut wall and the liver, which convert most of it into glucose and glycogen.

In mice, the small intestine cleared about 90% of a small amount of fructose before it reached the liver. A large amount overwhelmed it and spilled through to the liver and the bacteria further down. That's the difference between an apple eaten slowly and a glass of juice drunk in a minute. A glass of orange juice is the sugar of several oranges, without the chewing and the fibre that slow it down, which puts it closer to a soft drink than to fruit.

Fruit is a dessert that grew on a tree. It was seasonal for most of human history, a few weeks of plenty before winter. Eaten all year, in bowlfuls and glassfuls, it's a steady sugar load dressed up as health food.

Soy and plant oestrogens

In the 1940s, farmers noticed that sheep grazing on certain pastures were having fewer lambs. The pastures were rich in subterranean and red clover, and the clover was full of plant oestrogens, compounds similar enough to the body's own hormone to bind its receptors.

Soy is where you're most likely to meet them. Its oestrogens, the isoflavones, are concentrated in soy protein isolate, the powder in protein shakes, meat substitutes and soy infant formula. Babies fed soy formula take in 22 to 45 milligrams of isoflavones a day. A breastfed baby gets less than a hundredth of a milligram. How much that matters in the long run is still argued over, but it's a remarkable gap for a food sold as gentle.

Soy also gets in the way of the thyroid hormone tablet levothyroxine, which is why those taking it are advised to space soy, along with walnuts, fibre and calcium and iron supplements, away from the tablet. The shake marketed to the fitness crowd and the formula marketed to new parents are the two places soy is most concentrated, and the people buying them are the ones paying most attention to what they eat.

Soy isn't the only food that leans on the thyroid. The cabbage family, from broccoli and kale to bok choy, carries compounds that can hinder the thyroid's uptake of iodine. In ordinary amounts, with enough iodine in the diet, the effect looks small. One case report shows the extreme. An 88-year-old woman ate roughly a kilogram or more of raw bok choy every day for several months, hoping it would help her diabetes, and her thyroid slowed so far that she fell into a coma. She recovered with treatment. Raw is the key word. Crushing the raw leaves releases an enzyme that frees those compounds, and cooking switches it off, so a blender full of raw leaves is the worst way to eat them.

What preparation can and can't do

Every one of these compounds is built into the plant. They aren't residues you can wash off, and organic certification changes nothing about the lectins in a bean or the oxalate in a leaf. What changes them is the kitchen. Boiling destroys lectins and pulls oxalate into the water. Soaking cuts lectins. Sprouting, sourdough and other ferments break phytate down. Whole fruit beats juice every time.

Your genes decide part of the cost, too. Fava beans, also called broad beans, carry compounds that flood red blood cells with oxidants. A healthy red cell neutralises them with the help of an enzyme called G6PD. More than 400 million people worldwide carry a gene that leaves them short of it, particularly in parts of Africa, Asia, the Mediterranean and the Middle East, and for them a plate of fava beans can set off a sudden breakdown of red blood cells, with anaemia and jaundice. The gene is thought to have spread because it gives some protection against malaria. Pythagoras made his followers swear off beans altogether, though the reasons recorded were mystical rather than medical. It's the same lesson as Oxalobacter: what a food does depends partly on who eats it.

Preparation reduces the load. It doesn't remove it. A plate built mostly on plants, however carefully cooked, still carries more of all five than a plate whose base is meat, fish and eggs, which carry none of these plant defences.

What it asks of you

For me the answer was a change of foundation. Meat, fish and eggs are the base, because they bring their iron, zinc and protein without anything binding them or blocking them. Plants are the side, picked and prepared with care: cooked greens instead of raw ones, fermented instead of fast, whole fruit as an occasional treat rather than a daily habit. The Carnivore Code makes the case for the animal-food side of that plate.

The other kind of harm arrives from outside, in sprays, oxidised oils, additives and packaging. Unlike the compounds here, that's where buying organic and reading labels actually gives you leverage. What Gets Added to Your Food Before It Reaches You (linked below) covers that half. And if your body keeps reacting to food in ways no test explains, Food Allergies, Sensitivities, and Intolerances (linked below) sorts out which kind of reaction you might be having.

What I got wrong

I spent years certain I was helping people by recommending more plants. What I passed on was accurate as far as it went: vegetables do contain vitamins, fibre does move through the gut, whole grains do beat white bread. What I left out was the other half of the equation, what those foods cost the body to process. I had never asked the question that small study put to me.

The plant on your plate didn't grow to feed you. It grew to survive being eaten. Cook it well, keep it on the side, and build the meal on the foods that never needed to defend themselves from you.


Keep reacting to food that's supposed to be good for you? Food Allergies, Sensitivities, and Intolerances: Why Your Body Keeps Reacting to Food That's Supposed to Be Good for You — the three kinds of food reaction, what each test can and can't see, and how to track down your own trigger.

Wondering what happens to food after it leaves the field? What Gets Added to Your Food Before It Reaches You — the residues, oils and additives that arrive from outside, and where reading the label actually helps.


Know someone who eats carefully and still feels off? Send them this. The foods doing the damage may be the ones they chose for their health.

Tried something here, or got a question it didn't answer? Write to us at contact@allforlife.club. Your questions shape the next articles.


Disclaimer: This article is general information, not medical or nutritional advice. If you have kidney disease, a history of kidney stones, take thyroid medication or are feeding a baby, talk to a qualified health professional before changing your diet.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, All For Life earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. We only link to products we would recommend without the commission.


Sources

Young JF, Dragsted LO, Haraldsdóttir J, et al. (2002). Green tea extract only affects markers of oxidative status postprandially: lasting antioxidant effect of flavonoid-free diet. British Journal of Nutrition 87(4):343–355. doi.org/10.1079/BJN2002523

Dragsted LO, Pedersen A, Hermetter A, et al. (2004). The 6-a-day study: effects of fruit and vegetables on markers of oxidative stress and antioxidative defense in healthy nonsmokers. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 79(6):1060–1072. doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/79.6.1060

Wikipedia. Plant defense against herbivory. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Amygdalin. en.wikipedia.org

Shi L, Arntfield SD, Nickerson M (2018). Changes in levels of phytic acid, lectins and oxalates during soaking and cooking of Canadian pulses. Food Research International 107:660–668. doi.org/10.1016/j.foodres.2018.02.056

Wikipedia. Lectin. en.wikipedia.org

Freed DL (1999). Do dietary lectins cause disease? BMJ 318(7190):1023–1024. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.318.7190.1023

Chai W, Liebman M (2005). Effect of different cooking methods on vegetable oxalate content. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 53(8):3027–3030. doi.org/10.1021/jf048128d

Wikipedia. Rhubarb. en.wikipedia.org

Noonan SC, Savage GP (1999). Oxalate content of foods and its effect on humans. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 8(1):64–74. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Makkapati S, D'Agati VD, Balsam L (2018). "Green Smoothie Cleanse" Causing Acute Oxalate Nephropathy. American Journal of Kidney Diseases 71(2):281–286. doi.org/10.1053/j.ajkd.2017.08.002

Wikipedia. Oxalobacter formigenes. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Primary hyperoxaluria. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Phytic acid. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Edward Mellanby. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Zinc deficiency. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Fructose. en.wikipedia.org

Jang C, Hui S, Lu W, et al. (2018). The Small Intestine Converts Dietary Fructose into Glucose and Organic Acids. Cell Metabolism 27(2):351–361. doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2017.12.016

Wikipedia. Phytoestrogen. en.wikipedia.org

Setchell KD, Zimmer-Nechemias L, Cai J, Heubi JE (1998). Isoflavone content of infant formulas and the metabolic fate of these phytoestrogens in early life. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 68(6 Suppl):1453S–1461S. doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/68.6.1453S

Wikipedia. Levothyroxine. en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia. Goitrogen. en.wikipedia.org

Chu M, Seltzer TF (2010). Myxedema coma induced by ingestion of raw bok choy. New England Journal of Medicine 362(20):1945–1946. doi.org/10.1056/NEJMc0911005

Wikipedia. Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency. en.wikipedia.org